How to Become a Manager: A Guide for Aspiring Leaders

Ever thought about becoming a manager? Want to know what it takes and how to move up from your individual contributor role?

Becoming a manager opens a whole new world of opportunity. With the right mindset and skills, you’ll find it is interesting, challenging, and rewarding. It also comes with new responsibility and usually higher pay (which is always nice!).

Whether you just started thinking about becoming a manager, or have known you’ve wanted to be one for a while, we’re here to help you.

how to become a manager - avoid the chicken or the egg conundrum

Fact: You rarely get hired to do things you haven’t done before

Unfortunately, becoming a manager is not the easiest career step. Especially for roles like management, most companies only want to hire people with experience already.

What then are you supposed to do?

At Lighthouse, we’ve covered a wide variety of management topics, including what to look for in potential leaders and how to help new managers succeed. With that research and experience, we know what most managers are looking for when they work to identify new leaders to promote.

You might not have management experience yet, but you can position yourself so that you’re seen as an ideal candidate for the next management position that opens up. And if you do that, you’ll also be setting yourself up to be a great manager in the process.

How to Become a Manager: Tips for getting noticed and developing yourself into a successful, future manager

The good news: There are certain qualities that any good manager or CEO knows to look for in a potential manager. This means you can work to develop and display these qualities clearly to get noticed, and be ready to lead well when given the opportunity.

Here are 5 tips to help you get noticed and start developing yourself into a future manager:

Get Lighthouse - How to Become a Manager

1) Become a manager for the right reasons

Becoming a manager requires the willingness to learn new things– a lot of new things– and be challenged. It’s a career change as much as it is a promotion, so make sure that becoming a manager is what you really want.

There are a lot of reasons you might want to be a manager, but only some of them are good reasons. If you’re not careful, you can end up in a job you don’t like. Consider carefully these reasons, so you make the right decision.

1. You’re doing it for the challenge of helping others and learning new skills, NOT the money

Managers that take the position for the money tend to run into a variety of problems, and eventually fail.

First, they often keep doing their old job in many ways, instead of embracing the growth and new skills needed. Then, as they struggle, they bring a bad attitude to their team over time that makes everyone else unhappy, too. As things get worse, they then hide from problems that could eventually result in them losing their position (and the money they thought they wanted).

There’s nothing wrong with liking the pay boost. However, your main reasoning for wanting to become a manager needs to be something deeper than that. That includes the desire for growth, challenge, or simply the fulfillment you get from the added responsibility or from building up and helping others.

2. You like working with & helping people

Being a manager is all about working with others and supporting them. If you love working with others, you’re a natural fit for management. If not, it’s probably not right for you as you’ll run away from the moments you’re needed most and your team is trying to reach you.

When people take management roles without the desire to help, collaborate, and work regularly with others, there’s no rapport or trust built. In fact, people can feel betrayed, as they don’t know who to turn to for help, and can’t get help fixing problems that are core to a manager’s job.

Other people’s problems become things you have to think about if you want to be a manager. You won’t get to solve them all, but you will have to want to understand them so you can help where you should.

3. You’re willing to give up being an individual contributor

To be a good manager, you need to shift from being an individual contributor to someone who focuses on how they can improve their team. You’re a multiplier (more on this later).

This is a critical mindset shift as it’s the difference between an extra hour of productivity here and there for you vs. dozens of hours for your team. Each time you sit down and work on making your team more effective can lead to exponential results because you’re dealing with an entire team of people.

how to become a manager - have a growth mindset

4. You have a growth mindset

A growth mindset is critical to becoming a manager. You have to believe that you (and others) can learn new skills, even if you’re starting from scratch. No one is a natural; everyone can achieve some level of ability with hard work.

There’s a lot to learn when shifting from IC work to being someone whose entire focus is making a team work more effectively. If you don’t have a growth mindset, it’s going to be impossible to learn everything you need to know to do your job well.

While great managers roll up their sleeves and learn, you’ll be thinking, “I’m just not good at ____.” This will hold you and your team back from the success they could have.

Most importantly, as a leader, you also influence the rest of your team. If you’re not willing to learn and grow, your team will take the cue and be less likely to embrace learning as well.

5. You love your job

Engagement plays a huge role in workplace productivity and retention. If you don’t enjoy your job, you’ll have a hard time performing at a high level.

If you don’t like your job, or the the company you work at, you should not become a manager there. It will only make things worse for you and your team.

Unfortunately, this is a common problem, which is called the “cascade effect” by Gallup:

Get Lighthouse - How to Become a Manager

Put simply, if your boss doesn’t like their job, or is disengaged, then there’s a good chance you won’t either.

Rarely does a bad situation get better just because you got promoted, so beware of becoming a manager at a company or role you don’t like. Not only will it likely end badly for you, it will also hurt your team.

Coming full circle, you can see that with all the reasons you should or should not become a manager, your decisions affect more than you. Be mindful of that and choose wisely when, or if, you become a manager.

Not sure if management is for you? Here’s some of the most common reasons people become bad managers.

how to become a manager - teach others

2) Show you have the ability to teach others

A big part of management is the ability to coach and teach others. There are a million teachable moments and important times to grow your people as a manager.

Being someone who is comfortable coaching can be a big plus when making your case for a new management opportunity. But how can you do that when you’re not already a manager? Mentor.

Mentor a teammate

Mentoring sits in the relationship management quadrant of emotional intelligence skills, a critical set of skills every manager needs to develop:

Get Lighthouse - How to Become a Manager

Mentoring is highly effective, as researchers Rose Opengart and Laura Bierema from the University of Georgia discovered. They found that employees who get regular mentoring attain higher positions, better pay, and report more career satisfaction.

If you can show you have the ability to mentor and teach another teammate, you’re displaying an important leadership skill that every great manager possesses. It’s also a great way to get noticed for another reason: you’re showing tangible proof of your ability to lead and manage others.

Not sure where to start? Consider asking if you can help mentor an intern first.

Most interns could use more support than they get, and companies would like to say they give lots of mentorship to them. Best of all, it’s low-risk for all of you. An intern will be gone at the end of the summer, and so any mistakes will soon be forgotten, and you’ll have a natural end to the process in case you don’t like it.

If they come back with positive reviews, you can then push for more opportunities, likely with full time teammates.

Develop your writing skills

Communication skills are vital to being a good manager. You’ll be regularly communicating with your team, to other teams, and up your company’s org chart regularly.

While this communication will take many forms (meetings, presentations, emails, calls, etc), writing will be a big part of many of them.  Further, with the rise of remote work, writing has never been a more important part of that set of skills, as written word replaces many face to face moments in an office.

Get Lighthouse - How to Become a Manager

Online communication can make it difficult to discern intent, as former Chairman and CEO of Pepsi Indra Nooyi has pointed out. That’s because we’re lacking critical cues from things such as body language.

As a result, our natural tribal instincts nudge us toward defensiveness while we assume negative intent of others. Unfortunately, that results in conflict.

This means that the ability to communicate effectively, in a way that avoids this kind of conflict, is more valuable than ever.

You can develop your writing skills in a variety of ways:

  • Write a blog post to teach others something you know.
  • Create Google, Word Docs, or a wiki entry on a topic to help your teammates or colleagues on a topic.
  • Step up and take notes in a meeting, or own updating other teams on your team’s progress.

Not only does this give you more visibility to others that you take initiative and have important things to say, it also:

  • Helps you clarify what you know and get better at organizing ideas.
  • Improves your ability to clearly communicate your thoughts in written form, improving your communication skills

The first step to becoming a manager is often taking initiative. Stepping up to help others, improve communication in your team or across others, and writing well are all signs you could be a leader to those that decide who could become a manager next.

how to become a manager - me to we

3) Make others around you better

One of the most fundamental changes every good manager needs to adopt is switching from an individual contributor (IC) mindset to a multiplier mindset.

Before you become a manager, you focus on maximizing your productivity and efficiency. It’s all shipping that code, completing that copy, or hitting that sales goal.

But once you become a manager, it’s far more effective to ask, “How can I make my team more productive and efficient as a whole?” This is what it means to adopt a multiplier mindset.

As an individual contributor, it’s just you. But as a manager, you can take steps to make your entire team more productive and literally multiply your team’s efforts. One is productivity, the other is productivity on steroids as Camille Fournier, author of The Manager’s Path, and former CTO of Rent the Runway explained in her Velocity NY 2014 keynote:

Think of creative ways to make your team better

Adopting a multiplier mindset is at the core of what it means to become a great manager. When you make others around you better, more effective, or unblocked, you maximize their potential.

By showing that you have the ability to make those around you better, you’ll start to be seen as a potential future manager.

How do I become a multiplier?

Chances are, you know your teammates well. At least, well enough to know what some of their challenges are and some of the problems the team is facing as a whole.

Use that knowledge to think of creative ways to make your team better. If something or someone is serving as a bottleneck, or some work is inefficient or ineffective, here’s how you can help:

  1. Talk with those affected: Shopping ideas, getting buy in (especially a first follower), and collaborating on solutions are key to bringing effective change.
  2. Volunteer to help: Bosses order people around. Leaders show the way. You can always step up and be a part of a solution, but be careful volunteer other people without their agreement.
  3. Collaborate with your manager: Your manager may or may not be aware of a problem. Coming to them shows you understand how to manage up, and if you also bring a solution, they then can trust you can resolve problems, too.

By being proactive, and inclusive in how you find problems and help to resolve them, you’ll show your peers and your manager that you can effectively lead. You’ll also be demonstrating you’re a multiplier as you unleash your coworkers to do more of their best work.

Other tips for getting noticed by making your team better

You might not be a manager yet, but you can start thinking about ways you can get noticed as a multiplier within your team. Here are some more examples to get you thinking:

  • Use one on ones with your manager to point out insights related to multiplying your team’s productivity or efficiency. Your manage hears a small fraction of what’s actually happening on your team. If there’s helpful way (*not gossip/politics) to let them know about a problem, opportunity, or idea to make things better, put it on your 1 on 1 agenda.
  • Does something unsexy need done? Step up. A lot of the work of managers is unglamorous. If no one else does something, it often falls on the manager. If you can take ownership of some of those things, you can make a strong impression.
  • Bring solutions, not just problems. We mentioned it and it bears repeating: you make the best impression with your manager if when you present a problem, you also have at least a foundation for the solution. Otherwise, it feels like you’re just putting more on their busy plate.

Learning to think like a multiplier is often a big mindset shift. The more you can start thinking that way, and effectively helping make those around you better, the more you’ll be ready to be a great manager.

Get Lighthouse - How to Become a Manager

4) Learn from the best managers (and become a lifelong learner)

There’s a lot that goes into being a manager. Most who take the job go into it completely unaware of just how different it is from their current position, be it an engineer, marketer, sales person, or other.

As Lindsay Holmwood, Engineering Manager at Envato remarked on his blog, management is a career change:

“If you want to do your leadership job effectively, you will be exercising a vastly different set of skills on a daily basis to what you are exercising as an engineer. Skills you likely haven’t developed and are unaware of.”

You’ll need to become a lifelong learner if you want to be a great manager. The good news is, this is yet another way to get noticed while simultaneously developing yourself.

Becoming a life-long learner

According to Standford psychologist Carol Dweck, a growth mindset makes a critical difference in virtually every way when it comes to learning and development. And it’s especially important for managers.

Those with a fixed mindset believe intelligence is fixed, which affects their ability to handle challenges, criticism, and work with others. Meanwhile, those with a growth mindset embrace challenges, learn from criticism, and learn from others who succeed.

Get Lighthouse - How to Become a Manager

As we talked about earlier, a growth mindset is necessary for new managers because there’s a lot you need to learn. It’s also this growth mindset which is a key factor that great leaders know to look for in potential managers; they know that the only way a new manager succeeds is if they’re ready, willing, and able to rapidly learn and build new skills.

With this in mind, if you display this mindset through a willingness to learn and grow, you’ll help yourself get noticed while improving at the same time.

how to become a manager, learn from others

Study those you admire

The best examples to learn from are those managers you already know and admire. If you had, or have, a manager you love then look to them. What makes them so great? Try to pinpoint what makes them different from a bad manager you might have had in the past.

Also look to those founders, CEOs, and managers from other companies whom you follow and admire.

Start seeing their advice from the perspective of someone who leads people as a profession. Seek to emulate them and apply what lessons you can to your position now to help get you noticed.

Look to books for the greatest management lessons

Books are a great place to look as well. Many of the greatest modern leaders have put out books with all their best lessons summarized in a few hundred pages.

Whether you’re an aspiring manager or you’re preparing for a new promotion into management, these are one of the best places to look if you want to learn how to become a better manager quickly.

Here are several books we recommend for all future, would-be, or current managers alike:

Get Lighthouse - How to Become a Manager

High Output Management by Andy Grove

Andy Grove’s High Output Management remains one of the most influential books on management nearly 35 years since it was written. Leaders across many industries swear by it.

As a manager, you’ll be faced with many new challenges you’ve likely never faced before. You’ll have to work through issues with team members, attend countless meetings, and learn how to go from an individual contributor to a multiplier. Grove’s classic will teach you how to deal with all of this and more.

Further reading from the blog on one of our favorite leaders, Andy Grove:

Get Lighthouse - How to Become a Manager

How to Win Friends and Influence People by Dale Carnegie

Written in 1937, How to Win Friends and Influence People remains one of the best books ever written on leadership.

The book will help you avoid rookie mistakes like assuming the worst and bossing your team around. Instead, Carnegie will show you how to understand and work with others better in countless ways.

If Grove’s book is the tactical manual to the processes of effective management, then Carnegie’s book is the companion for all the soft skills of being an effective leader.

Get Lighthouse - How to Become a Manager

Creativity, Inc. by Ed Catmull

Ed Catmull is one of the cofounders of a little animation studio called Pixar. He helped guide the studio to success, culminating in its purchase by Disney for $7.4 billion, and a stunning run of dozens of hit movies you’ve likely seen and love.

Catmull’s Creativity, Inc. is part-autobiography, as it takes you through the story of a dream two decades in the making. However, it’s also one of the best books on leadership and management in the past decade, especially for managers of teams doing creative work. It helps you straddle the line between being pro-active and re-active, as well as building a culture of candor and accountability.

Further reading from the blog on Ed Catmull:

Embracing a mindset of ongoing growth and learning is a great way to ensure you’re always growing. As you do, you’ll likely find it’s a lot of fun learning the inside story on how others have succeeded. As you do, you may like some of the other books and authors we’ve profiled on the Lighthouse blog including:


How to become a manager - get on a rocketship

5) Join a company that’s growing

Think of the effort you’re putting into becoming a manager and leader as an investment in yourself. You don’t want to make a bad investment.

Just as there are several different ways to invest in real estate, stocks, etc., you get to choose, to some degree, what company you invest your time and life in.

If you choose a company that’s growing quickly and consistently promoting from within, you’ll have many opportunities to move up. This is much better than waiting for your boss to leave or get fired.

Unfortunately, if you are working at a company that isn’t growing, your opportunities are reduced quite a bit. If you’re in that kind of situation, you may want to look for another company to join, who will then later give you the opportunity to become a manager.

Get Lighthouse - How to Become a Manager - goals dilbert don't care

Choose a company that promotes from within

If your company isn’t promoting from within, that could be just as bad as one that isn’t growing at all for your hopes of becoming a manager. The former may overlook your potential and interest in managing in favor of hiring in other, experienced leaders.

Ideally, you want to invest your time in a company that has a track record of rewarding leadership potential with management roles. You’ll notice this by looking at the Linkedin profiles of people at the company to see who has been there a few years and if they’ve been promoted.

If you’re interviewing, ask how they support new managers. Do they provide new or soon-to-be managers with resources to learn about and move more easily into their new position? Do they provide management training of any kind? And do they invest in developing leadership as a whole?

It’s often difficult to learn everything in an interview process. However, if you have your choice of options, choose the one that seems to be the best mix of growth potential, habit of promoting from within, and supporting leaders once they’re promoted.

Start acting like a manager

You don’t have to be a manager now to start thinking and acting more like one.

Great managers don’t strut around like Lumbergh from Office Space: passive-aggressively bossing their team around while pushing for status updates every five minutes.

Get Lighthouse - How to Become a Manager - bad bosses lumbergh

Instead, they’re thoughtful, aware, and think at scale. They seek to listen to each team member and work with them to overcome issues. They want to know your goals and seek to help you achieve them and improve. Also, they’re always thinking about how they can help their team do exponentially more.

You can learn to do many of these things even without the title.

Be mindful of what is outside of your scope of responsibility, and don’t step on any toes. However, if you come from a mindset of caring about others and wanting to make things better, you’ll find most people are happy to have you make things better.

If you start working on some of the areas we’ve covered today, you’ll be far more likely to get noticed as someone with leadership potential and a future manager when the opportunity presents itself.  You can do that by:

  • Having interest in being a manager for the right reasons
  • Showing that you have the ability to teach others
  • Making those around you better
  • Learning from the best managers, and living their lessons
  • Investing your time in a company that’s growing and is intentional about promoting from within.

Being a manager is as challenging as it is rewarding. By following these tips, you’ll be more likely to get noticed, and be well-prepared for the role when you do get to become a manager.

To learn more about what makes a great manager, read: 

And when you become a manager, sign up for a free trial of Lighthouse, which is purpose built to make it is easy for you to be a great leader.