Good Manager vs Bad Manager: How a Good Manager is Worth $192,375 More

“The greatest leader is not necessarily the one who does the greatest things. He is the one that gets the people to do the greatest things.” – Ronald Reagan, 40th President of the United States

“No man will make a great leader who wants to do it all himself, or get all the credit for doing it.” – Andrew Carnegie, Steel magnate and philanthropist

“The wicked leader is he who the people despise. The good leader is he who the people revere. The great leader is he who the people say, ‘We did it ourselves.'” Lao-Tzu, ancient Chinese philosopher & author of the Tao Te Ching

Across generations and cultures, everyone agrees on the importance of great leaders. Given the choice, anyone will clearly say they’d rather have a good manager than a bad one.

We know that people leave managers, not companies, but rarely does anyone put a price on what bad managers do to drive down performance and increase turnover. When we look at a good manager vs bad manager in the workplace, no one seems to put a dollar value to that crucial difference.

What’s the real difference?

How much is a good manager really worth? How do you measure the value of good management?

And how much does a bad manager really cost you?

Today, we tackle those questions. We’ll show you step by step how you can show the difference in value for a good manager vs bad manager and apply it to your company.

If you’ve ever wanted to make the case for investing more in developing your managers to be great, here’s your template. You can finally show all the money being left on the table by neglecting to improve or replace your bad managers.

good manager vs bad manager cash left on the table is huge

Why the difference for a Good Manager vs Bad Manager is over $192,375

Sadly, there’s rarely a way to just look and clearly see the financial difference between teams run by a good manager vs bad manager.

For those of you in non-sales disciplines, it’s hard to tell even where to begin. There’s a reason that Google’s People Analytics team had to do extensive studies to determine the value of managers.

Fortunately, we’ve cracked the code. By combining some simple numbers about your company with key research by Gallup and others, we can create a strong estimate of the value of a good manager.

good manager vs bad manager show your math to calculate their roi

Show your work!

Like a proof in math class, we’re going to show all our work. This way you can adjust based on your situation.

Think a number is high? Adjust it down. Too low? Raise it. We use whole, round numbers as much as possible to make that easier for you.

While you may need to tweak a few of our assumptions to fit perfectly, the end result will be the same: a good manager vs bad manager is no contest. Even we were surprised just how big a difference there is between them.

Baseline figures:

We had a few key assumptions that drive our calculations. Here’s those baseline numbers, and their sources (when applicable).

1) Average Team Member’s Salary: $100,000/year

Depending on where you are, this may be too high or low. Either way, this makes it easy to adjust:

  • If your average salary is $75,000, just multiply the number by 0.75.
  • If your average salary is $150,000, just multiply the number by 1.5.

2) Revenue per Employee: $200,000/year

According to research by Venture Capitalist Tomasz Tunguz, “the typical average revenue per employee is about $190k to $210k per year” for a venture backed SaaS company. Once again, this is an easy, round number to tweak to fit your company.

If you don’t know yours, just use this simple formula to estimate it:

good manager vs bad manager revenue per employee calculation

3) Average Team Size: 10

Experts like Jeff Bezos, Michael Lopp (aka- Rands in Repose), and Tomasz Tunguz agree that it’s hard for anyone to manage more than 10 people well. However, as companies rapidly grow, teams can often swell so that most managers have such big teams.

Once again, this is also a helpful round number to easily adjust if your teams are smaller.

4) Cost of Replacing an Employee: $65,500

We’ve broken down this number before, so you can see all our work on the cost of replacing an employee here. This is also based on a $100,000 a year employee salary, so everything is consistent.

good manager vs bad manager summary of costs to replace an employee

With these baseline numbers in mind, let’s dive into the calculations.

The Value of a Good Manager vs Bad Manager: Engagement

One of the biggest differences a good manager makes is in the level of engagement of their team. According to Gallup, a manager accounts for the majority (70%) of the variance in employee engagement.

In Gallup’s comprehensive research on managers and teams, they found that the specific impact of having more engaged employees was all of the following:

good manager vs bad manager engagement is a key measure

While you could put a dollar value on issues like shrinkage, safety incidents, and absenteeism, we’re going to focus on the two biggest drivers: Productivity & Profitability. These apply to every company and happen to be basically equal (21% vs 22%).

good manager vs bad manager there is a big differene in profitability and productivity

Calculating the value of higher engagement

Since we know that managers drive the majority of an engagement score for an employee, we can then assume that a good manager has a mostly engaged team. Meanwhile, a bad manager is likely no better than the dismal average engagement score Gallup has reported over the past few years of 30%:

good manager vs bad manager enagement scores by gallup show what we can expect a bad manager to be

With this in mind, we can estimate how many more engaged employees a good manager has with a team of 10:

good manager vs bad manager employees are more engaged for good ones

Knowing that a good manager will engage 4 more people, we can then go back to our earlier data and calculate the value they’re bringing to their more engaged team:

good manager vs bad manager total value for higher employee engagement on their team

Wow! A good manager adds almost an entire additional employee’s worth of revenue just because they’ve engaged their team more effectively.

This should not surprise you. A team working well together, and that’s highly motivated, is going to do the extra things that add up:

  • Go the extra mile for a customer that has a problem.
  • Work late on a critical project to go from “good enough” to “Let’s wow them.”
  • Get more done due to fewer disruptions, distractions, and conflicts.

Think back to the last great manager you had. I bet you can recall situations where you and some of your team members worked harder to drive a big impact. You don’t need very many of those events throughout a year to significantly impact your bottom line.

The Value of a Good Manager vs Bad Manager: Turnover

While the value from better engagement can be hidden, the turnover on a manager’s team is much easier to spot. When people leave your team it costs you in a variety of ways:

  • Lost productivity: You suddenly have one less person to help get things done.
  • Sourcing: You have to spend time and money finding candidates to interview.
  • Interviewing: You and your team have to spend time interviewing candidates.
  • Onboarding: A new employee takes time to get up to speed and needs trained.

This adds up fast. In fact, as we found, it costs you $65,500 when you lose an employee. And unfortunately, it doesn’t end there.

Calculating the value of reduced turnover

As Gallup’s data showed, engaged employees are less likely to quit by a rate ranging from 25% to 65%:

good manager vs bad manager fewer people quit good managers

Given that employees leave in waves, and Gallup found so much of engagement is due to the manager, this makes sense.

If one person is unhappy with their relationship with their manager, it’s likely some of their teammates are, too.  And when one person decides it’s time to interview somewhere else, they probably tell some of their colleagues. It doesn’t take long for many on a team to seek, and obtain other jobs.

Looking at data from CompData Surveys of over 28,000 companies, the amount of voluntary turnover across industries has hovered around 10% in recent years:

good manager vs bad manager turnover changes

With this in mind, we can estimate the turnover rate for teams in both low turnover and high turnover organizations by combining the Gallup and CompData numbers:

Good manager vs bad manager turnover is different for each

If we assume a good manager is going to only lose the industry average of 1 out of 10 staff members a year (10%), a bad manager has a higher probability of having to replace a second employee.  For particularly bad managers, this is likely greatly underestimating just how many people may flee their team.

Knowing that a good manager will avoid losing another team member, we can calculate the savings from their improved retention in either case:

good manager vs bad manager value

Depending on your company, your good managers are saving you $16,000 to $42,000 every year because they’re better at retaining their teams. If you have hard to find talent that will be more painful to replace, or really bad managers that drive away many more team members, this number can quickly skyrocket.

The Value of a Good Manager vs Bad Manager: Putting it all together

Knowing the overall value of a good manager vs bad manager for both engagement gains and turnover savings, now we can add it all up.  This total gain is the value of a single good manager at your company.

good manager vs bad manager total savings

What do I do with this number?!?

Depending on your organization’s overall turnover rate, every good manager has a $192,000 to $218,000 higher value than their bad manager counterpart.

This means that any investment you make in trying to improve your bad managers can have this amount of ROI for every single bad manager you convert to a good one.

If you’re trying to justify investing in new staff or programs, estimate how many bad managers you can impact. Multiply it by this number and you have the major impact you can have on your organization, regardless of your size.

How do you make more good managers?

Being a good manager is not a secret. It’s a series of repeatable habits that Gallup, Google, Deloitte, and many other companies have researched and applied to their teams.

Training, classes, and videos only go so far. It’s the habits your managers have day in and day out that really matter to their teams.

If you’re looking for help getting your managers to consistently do the habits that separate a good manager vs bad manager, then sign up for a free trial of Lighthouse or a call to learn more here.

Built with the latest workplace research, and timeless management best practices, it can help more of your managers experience the gains of a retained, engaged team.

You can learn more at GetLighthouse.com